Friday, August 16, 2013

Tracking community change in the nearshore zone

A red sea urchin (Stronglyocentrotus franciscanus) with a transect survey tape draped over it, at a site off of the Elwha River mouth)

Coastal resilience is not just about the physical interactions (erosion, flooding, tsunami) between the ocean and coastal communities. The concept also includes ecosystems, and the ability of coastal ecosystems (which support coastal communities) to respond to changes. In that vein, I've continued with a project I helped to initiate while a graduate student at UCSC designed to assess how the Elwha dam removal will change or affect the marine biological community that lives in the coastal zone adjacent to the Elwha River delta. Originally a USGS project, our team is now a nice example of multi-agency collaboration, with contributions from USGS, the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, WA Sea Grant, EPA and the US Coast Guard. We've just wrapped up our second of three sessions this summer, working to collect data on the fish, invertebrate and algae community at >20 sites at the Elwha and two reference areas (Green Point and Low Point). We also deploy and recover sensors logging temperature and light data, and measure information on the substrate.

There are a few interesting observations from the summer. We've been astonished by the recruitment of juvenile Dungeness Crab (Metacarcinus magister) at many of our sites. Check this video from a site near the base of Ediz Hook:

Our data set really isn't effective at detecting changes in these sorts of mobile and patchy species over time, but we can say that we've never seen anything like this before at our sites. Does it somehow have something to do with the removal? With ocean conditions? Pretty intriguing...

Next, we've hypothesized that the seafloor along parts of the shallow nearshore of the Elwha coastal zone would see substrate transitions as sediment from the Elwha River mouth enters the coastal environment. Furthermore, we expect that new habitats and biological communities would develop in these areas. At most sites, though, (outside of those sites that are more or less right in the river mouth) we haven't yet detected a dramatic shift in the substrate (from gravel to sand, for example)...but there is now at least one notable exception. At a site in shallow water (~25 feet) about 500 yards to the east of the river mouth we've tracked the arrival of sand from the river, which now entirely covers the seafloor. This video, for example, was shot in September of 2009:

That seem piece of sea-floor now looks like this:

We've been able to constrain the timing of the arrival of this sand to the last two months. Now, in the years ahead, our goal will be to assess if this material sticks around, and if and how a different biological community takes shape in these areas.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

On the water with ORCAs

The way in...literally and metaphorically for many students!

No, not Orcinus orca...the Ocean Research College Academy, an Everett Community College-based program and creation of director (and biologist, mentor, educator, USCG certified captain, grant-writer, development specialist...the list goes on and on) Ardi Kveven. I met Ardi at the ASLO conference in New Orleans in 2013, and was stunned that I hadn't heard of her program before. They use a cohort approach, serving running start students at Everett Community college with ocean sciences as the unifying concept behind core learning in English, Math, Science, History, etc. The students take part in monthly (give or take) cruises in Possession Sound and, at this point (~10 years in) have an astonishing long term data set, not to mention a track record of student success.

I joined cruise #64, with the Hat Island ferry as our research platform. My goal in going was to: 1) try to understand more about how to do STEM education and ocean sciences education right (Ocean Literacy and Workforce Development is one of WA Sea Grant's Critical Program Areas) and also 2) try to steal as many ideas as I could for my own Oceanography class at Peninsula College.

I definitely got what I came for - I'm impressed. I had a great day talking to students, watching them deploy instruments, manage data and samples, and describe their processes to me. A few more photos of the day:

pre-cruise prep in the lab

ORCA's location in the Everett Marina makes the trip to the research vessel a breeze - a 5 minute walk

pre-cruise briefing

Students from ORCA prepare to deploy instruments off of the bow of the Hat Island ferry

An ORCA student handles a sediment sample

Just a taste of ORCA's beautiful new shore facility

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

The Changing Elwha River mouth...in pictures

Many of us have marveled at some of the photography coming out of the Elwha, from people like Tom Roorda and John Gussman (amongst others). Their imagery tells the story of the removal and restoration better than the science in most cases.

But on the science side of the project, photography is being used more and more as a measurement tool, from which all sorts of relevant information can be extracted. On the beach we use images to measure beach grain size. And Andy Ritchie, at Olympic National Park, has worked out a nice method, known as the "PlaneCam", to collect very inexpensive orthoimages, which allow for very precise measurements of landscape features. These images are being used to measure how the river and reservoirs are changing during dam removal, and are also used to assess how the shoreline is changing over time.

Towards that end I compiled a time series of aerial orthimages, both from Andy's set and also anything collected before the dam removal started (these came from a variety of sources, credited in the film), to provide yet another perspective on how the Elwha dam removals are influencing the coastal zone, and specifically the mouth of the river...

Monday, July 1, 2013

Coastal Sediment Distribution from the Ledgewood Slide

Much of the toe of the Ledgewood slide has eroded back dramatically, consistent with time lapse photography from the site. The scarp is now quite steep and tall (3-5m throughout most of the slide - the survey pole in the photo is 2m high). In this photos, at the very base of the scarp, you can make out the darker uplifted clays that were so prominent on the toe immediately after the slide.

I've posted a few times now about the large Ledgewood slide on Whidbey Island, which happened early this year. I've had the opportunity to visit the slide three times now to both do some very small-scale surveying of the shoreline, as well as collect time lapse photos of the toe of the slide as it erodes. My overall goal is to generally contribute to the efforts to understand the slide as a whole, but specifically look at the coastal consequences of large bluff failures like this one. In particular I wanted to try to document where, how and how much sediment from the slide recruited to adjacent beaches.

My approach was to do repeat surveys on a small number of transects both on and adjacent to the slide toe. The first set was collected just a few days after the slide...and I finally made it out last week with a small group of Island County residents to repeat those surveys. In general, we found erosion of the sub-aerial portion of the slide - the toe material that was in or above the intertidal, and some indication of deposition of some sediment below MLLW (though this is scanty since we couldn't really work below about MLLW). We also found deposition on the intertidal beach both north and south of the slide. Here are some example profiles from on the bluff toe itself:

Beach profiles from three sources: 2001 aerial LIDAR (courtesy of the Puget Sound Lidar Consortium), which I use here as a suggestion of the pre-slide beach position, a 2 April 2013 profile (immediately post-slide), and the data we collected on 26 June 2013. On these transects in the middle of the slide the scarp became very steep and tall (>3 m; see photo above), and I wasn't able to collect data on the scarp itself, or on the upper surface due to both safety concerns and vegetation on the upper surface that would have blocked the GPS signal.

At either end of the slide I was able to survey to the same surface I surveyed on 2 April...more or less "connecting the dots"

The profile from the other end of the slide

Profiles from the beach adjacent to the slide suggest some deposition of that eroded material on the intertidal beach, but probably not too far north. Here are the profiles from two transects north of the slide:

This transect was the furthest north one that I collected on 2 April 2013, and there is limited, if any, deposition at this site 139 meters north of the toe of the slide.

By contrast the transect immediately north of the slide shows uniform deposition across the entire profile...about 1 m vertically.

The grain size data I've collected isn't ready for prime time yet, but you can get a sense for the grain size transition on the beach by looking at these photos, suggesting that the material accreted to the intertidal beach is a mix of lots of sand, and a good bit of gravel. These photos are on the profile line above, immediately north of the slide. Check out the first one, collected 2 April 2013:

and compare it to this one from 26 June, taken at approximately the same elevation on the beach (just above MLLW) and more or less the same perspective (note the shoreline protection in the far field to orient yourself.

Based on the very limited number of profiles that I measured, it does appear that more sediment from the slide has migrated south

Here are the profile data from the transect immediately south of the slide. Here too there is a fairly uniform deposition of 1 m of sediment across the intertidal profile. If you watch closely, this deposition, as well as some of the dynamics associated with the transport of sediment on to the beach, is visible in the time lapse video.

To the south, as we moved away from the toe of the slide, we were still seeing measurable accretion on the profile. This is the furthest south repeat profile that I have, but based on grain size variation we estimated that sediment from the toe of the slide had deposited on the intertidal beach at least 375 m south of the slide.

Back of the envelope estimates of sediment volumes, based on these very limited data, suggest on the order of 18,000 m3 eroded from the toe of the slide (that is probably a low estimate)...and ~2000 m3 deposited on the intertidal beach to the north, and maybe 6000 m3 deposited on the beach to the south. Again, VERY loose estimates...and based on the observations of a variety of people, if I had to guess, I would say that the remainder (>10,000 m3) has moved into the sub-tidal zone (below MLLW) or was finer material (mud, silt and clay) that was stripped off of the toe and moved away from the site by currents.

A special thank you to Paul Morris, Jan Wright, Mark Kennedy and Jan Kennedy for their help with this re-survey! Also, John Erlick for hosting my time lapse camera...

Monday, June 24, 2013

Surveying Dungeness Spit

The view landward from the lighthouse on the end of Dungeness Spit.

Randy Johnson, now at the Jamestown S'Klallam Tribe, has called the Strait of Juan de Fuca the "Land of Large Spits"...the ready sediment supply (primarily from eroding bluffs) combined with highly oblique wave energy in the Strait of Juan de Fuca create ideal conditions for spit evolution. Ediz Hook and Dungeness Spit in particular are fascinating features that dominate the shoreline of the Central Strait of Juan de Fuca. While they are similar in so many ways, Ediz Hook and Dungeness Spit have "grown apart" in a way over the past 100 years or so...Ediz Hook is highly modified, with a mill, a road, power, water and sewer lines plus armoring that runs nearly its entire length. By contrast Dungeness Spit is nearly pristine from a morphologic standpoint...few modifications to either the spit itself or the adjacent bluffs that are the source of some or all of the sediment to the spit.

The sign at the end of the spit...a suitable reminder regarding how far you've come

Spits are particularly vulnerable to climate change (via sea level rise, changes in wave climate, or other factors) and/or changes in sediment supply from up-drift sources (like eroding bluffs or, in some cases, rivers). In the case of Ediz Hook and Dungeness Spit, both features are incredibly important to coastal communities - Ediz Hook as a barrier for Port Angeles Harbor, and Dungeness Spit as a wildlife refuge and shallow water habitat. As a result I wanted to include both features in a shoreline monitoring program that I've been working on developing over the past year. On Saturday, in partnership with the University of Washington MeSSAGE program we finally had the opportunity to get out and survey the end of Dungeness Spit.

A student from the UW MeSSAGE program collecting grain size samples on the end of Dungeness Spit

The goal was to establish baselines for proposed morphology (primarily beach profiles) and beach grain size monitoring that would occur twice a year for the next few years at least. The idea is to build a dataset that would allow us to address unresolved questions like, "how does sediment supply from adjacent bluffs influence the morphology of the spit?", "what are the implications of sea level rise on spits?", and "What are the patterns of spit migration relative to wave climate, sea level variability, or other factors". I also was interested in doing some basic morphology characterization to compare to the results found by Maury Schwartz and his students during their field work in the 1980's...still the only peer-reviewed work on shoreline morphology from Dungeness Spit.

A student form the UW MeSSAGE Program conducts a topography survey with a backpack-mounted RTK-DGPS system

As a preliminary survey the day was hugely successful...it was a big operation, and we ran into the inevitable logistical hurdles, but in the end we walked away with thorough coverage for the end of the spit. The goal now is to compare our topo data to existing LiDAR data, run our grain size samples, and then prepare for the next survey...

topographic survey data coverage for our one-day survey

A huge thank you to the staff of the Dungeness Spit National Wildlife Refuge for permitting and logistical support. Also, this project simply wouldn't have happened without equipment support provided by the US Geological Survey and Peninsula College.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Flying the Elwha

On Tuesday I had the opportunity to fly over the Elwha watershed as part of a flight purchased by Nancy Fowler of Port Townsend as part of the Fish on the Fence fundraiser for the Feiro Marine Life Center. I've flown the valley multiple times now, and it never gets old, but given the scale of the change in the system I found myself wanting to dig up photos from some of the earlier flights I went on.

I started flying over the Elwha systematically in 2004 as part of a coastal monitoring program I initiated at the Surfrider Foundation. Here is a shot from one of those flights, on 22 June 2005:

and another from more or less the same perspective from this Tuesday's flight:

We didn't routine fly over the reservoirs, but every now and again I had the chance. Here is a shot of from before the dam removal started (taken on 27 June 2011)of the lower reservoir:

and its not a perfect match, but here is the view during Tuesday's flight:

and for the upper reservoir from 27 June 2011:

and again, not a perfect match, but the view from Tuesday's flight: